Uporedni test Srpska verzija

Audi A1 vs. MINI Cooper

Minimalism and Art Nouveau

MINI has finally got a real alternative, which comes from the same speaking country, namely, from Bavaria. In other words, there comes the Audi A1!

In an era of striving for political and any other correctness, it would be really unfair to call some cars “feminine”, but somehow, it imposes itself. When an automaker creates a new model, one of the first things that you pay attention to is the target customer group. So, the “unisex” models are usually declared as “feminine”, except “hairy” and “testosterone” (read “the fastest”) versions, which are due to the high performances and sporty looks, usually most appealing to the male part of the audience. Those are the exact models, with “R” and “S” badges that you can see “shooting up” in the neighborhood as gifts for the 18th birthday gifts for the girls who drive them to the Pilates, solarium or shopping mall.

The instrument panel is slightly oriented towards the driver, and the used materials and finish are at high level
The Audi A1 does not offer much in terms of space, although the front seats are almost like in the A3
The back seats are there only for short journeys and not particularly tall people
The A1’s 230 l luggage compartment is in the class average

In the category of small, “leisure class” models, MINI has been undisputed (the only one in the first place) king, and among its owners, there are drivers who love it for its features and understand what the brand represent. Whatever model showed up in the comparative test, MINI came out as a winner, proving again (and demonstrating) that timeless retro look and superior driving performances had no equal rivals.

Although the concept of the Mini was “born” in the UK and was greatly improved in Bavaria, this small “blue blood” city car did not have a competitor from the same language area – at least not yet. Now, a really “masculine” brand came on the scene – Audi. As already known, the Audi A1 began its life as Metroproject Quattro – a concept that announced the return of the brand to the small car category (who still remembers the Audi 60?).

Two Directions
In contrast to the direct rival (and favorite?), which is obviously characterized by the aforementioned retro lines, the “four rings” model features a modern design that suggests the Audi’s “techno” orientation. Since the test car came in traditional black color, A and C pillars came to the fore, as well as “silver” roof arches, reinforcing the aforementioned impression regarding the look of this car. Of course, LEDs are inevitable detail that is slowly but surely becoming the trademark of the second Bavarian car manufacturer.

To be completely honest, if Audi continues at such a pace, the big question is who should be called “the second Bavarian…” at the end of next year, but it’s another story that finds its place here as well, with few more pages in the content. In fact, Audi is rapidly expanding its range and recording significant achievements in terms of global sales. A1 will have its contribution for sure, proving even now to be a real hit and a true alternative to the MINI in the European markets.

Really Urban
One more domain where Audi built the image of a quality manufacturer was “interior”. The A1 is no exception. The instrument panel is slightly oriented towards the driver; the used materials and finish would assure even a “blindfolded” person that he is in a premium class car. Each element is nicely integrated into a whole, and details that stand out are in any case large central display and leather-trimmed steering wheel.

The Audi A1 is driven by a 1.4 TFSI unit which produces 122 “ponies” at 5000 rpm and 200 Nm at 1500-4000 rpm

Audi A1 1.4 TFSI

Engine
Type/cylinders gasoline, turbo, inline/4
Displacement [cm3] 1390
Valves/fuel injection type 16/direct
Max power [kW/hp/rpm] 90/122/5000
Torque [Nm/rpm] 200/1500-4000
Body
Type/seats/doors hatchback/5/3
L x W x H [mm] 3955x1710x1420
Wheelbase [mm] 2470
Vehicle weight/payload [kg] 1190/420
Boot capacity [l] 270-920
Suspension
front MacPherson, coil springs, shock absorbers, antiroll bar
rear multilink, coil springs, shock absorbers, antiroll bar
Brakes
front/rear int. ventilated discs/discs
Tires
dimensions 215/40 R17
Power transmission
FWD
Transmission type/gears DSG/7
Test data by Vrele Gume
Performance

acceleration 0-100 km/h [s] 9.3
top speed [km/h] 195
average fuel consumption [l/100 km] 5.4
noise at 100 km/h [dB] 65
Braking distance [m] 36.7
CO2 119 g
Price (with VAT) € from 20.938

On the other hand, the A1 do not offer much in terms of space, although the front seat position is almost like in the A3. The back seats are there only for short journeys and not particularly tall people, while the trunk has a volume of 270 l. It fits nicely in the class average, because the A1 is 3.95 m long, with the 2.47 m wheelbase.

Our old acquaintance, MINI was created by a well-known recipe called “each wheel in every corner of the car”. Thus, its overall length of 3.7 m (with almost identical wheelbase as Audi – the difference is only 2 mm) is really noticed only in terms of small trunk – 160 l. The impression, when we talk about the passenger compartment does not differ much, and the Audi offers a slightly wider space behind, while MINI can host two passengers there and offers more room for the heads. We have commented on the architecture of the instrument panel a lot of times – the large central speedometer, “aircraft” switches. What are also common for both models are excellent ergonomics and a low position at the steering wheel, but the exact difference is a subjective matter.

engine,
transmission,
design,
comfort

price,
back seat head room

Audi A1 has a rather high lateral line and the windshield is set with the much smaller angle towards the driver, so the driver feels quite “tucked”, which proved to positively affect his subjective impression of safety. MINI, on the other hand has almost vertically positioned windscreen and larger glass areas; it appears quite “airy”. So, as we said before, although in terms of dimensions pretty similar – they are very different in reality.

The Impression of the MINI Cooper’s cabin does not differ much from the Audi’s ...
… that offers a slightly wider space behind, while MINI can host two passengers there and offers more room for the heads
20 cm shorter MINI has as a result the smaller luggage compartment volume than the Audi - 160 liters (50/50 split folding rear seats)

Atmospheric or Turbo
The conclusion we have suggested previously considering interior refers also to what can be found under the hood. As the standards that regulate the quality of exhaust gases are becoming increasingly stringent, so the engine technology advancement is conditioned to follow those rules more than a need for higher performance. The only “cure” for this is use of turbines, in order to increase power and torque. That is the choice of Audi’s engineers, and A1 are offered with turbo engines only. The model we drove has a 1.4 TFSI unit which produces 122 “ponies” at 5000 rpm and 200 Nm at 1500-4000 rpm. Such data promises high performance and low fuel consumption and CO2 emission, but that has to be checked out, of course. The test car is equipped with the seven-speed DSG transmission, which Audi calls S-tronic.

However, MINI reserved the turbo technology for the most powerful version only. The tested Cooper has 1.6 l engine with 122 hp at 6000 rpm. Talking about the torque, all 160 Nm are available at 4000 rpm. It is a great result for the normally-aspirated engine, but in terms of torque availability in every everyday driving, it cannot fully match the features of turbo technology. If you want the Mini keeping pace with the A1, you should have its engine in higher revs. However, chronometer brought another surprise – Audi needs 9 seconds to reach 100 km/h, while MINI reaches the same speed in 9.2 seconds…

Audi A1 is also a little quieter. All other characteristics regarding drive are equal, including top speed and average fuel consumption, which can be kept within 6 l with moderate ride (no more than 8 l in the city). We were not able to reach factory data, but it was never common to achieve those features.

Polarization
However, what Audi gained from the comfort, more advanced engine, and really excellent gearbox (1900 € extra cost), Cooper made up with the driving characteristics. Simply, MINI still provides the best sense of control. Perhaps, some female hands would prefer the Audi A1 in the city drive, but the steering and suspension of the MINI simply “talks” with the driver and “tells” him what the well-balanced body “wants” to do. In this clash, the MINI is an athlete and the Audi is a gentleman.

MINIs turbo technology is reserved for the Cooper S; while our Cooper has a 1.6 liter naturally aspirated engine with 120 hp at 6000 rpm and 160 Nm at 4000

MINI Cooper

Engine
Type/cylinders gasoline, inline
Displacement [cm3] 1598
Valves/fuel injection type 16/multipoint
max power [kW/hp/rpm] 88/120/6000
torque [Nm/rpm] 160/4250
Body
type/seats/doors hatchback/5/3
L x W x H [mm] 3700x1685x1405
Wheelbase [mm] 2465
Vehicle weight/payload [kg] 1165/430
boot capacity [l] 160-680
Suspension
front double wishbone, coil springs, shock absorbers, antirollbar
rear multilink, coil springs, shock absorbers, antiroll bar
Brakes
front/rear int. ventilated discs/disc
Tires
dimensions 195/55 R16
Power transmission
FWD
transmission type/gears manual/6
Test data by Vrele Gume
Performance

acceleration 0-100 km/h [s] 9.8
top speed [km/h] 198
average fuel consumption [l/100 km] 5.7
noise at 100 km/h [dB] 66
braking distance [m] 36.0
CO2 133g
Price (with VAT) € from 19.990

They do not differ much in the terms of price either, but the Audi made a slight advantage in this area. The basic A1 with 1.2 TFSI engine (with 86 hp) costs 16,777 €, while the price for 1.4 TFSI is 19,024 €. Ticket to the MINI world will cost you 16,690 € for One (1.6 75 hp), while for the Cooper version you have to pay 19,990 €. Since the amount of standard equipment is nearly identical, satisfactory and in a way adequate to premium prices, the buyers of these cars will make a choice based on the design and character. Is there anything else to add?

The Conclusion
As we said before, these were two very similar, but at the same time very different cars. The values of the MINI brand are already well known, so we will not discuss them much, except that the tested car is still very actual model that even surpasses the newer competitors in the areas where it is the best – originality, great driving performances. The Audi A1, however, has some features that the MINI does not. The A1 has more torque at lower engine speed, it is quieter and slightly faster, but gives you a completely different impression during the drive. Because of this, Audi is not spoiling the MINI’s party and vice versa. The newcomer to car market is, in fact, a different alternative for the MINI, and there is plenty of room on the market for both of them. They are different enough, and it is hard to believe that the fans of either of them could change the favorite colors.

image,
driving characteristics,
design

price,
trunk

Unlike its direct rival, which is obviously characterized by the aforementioned retro-lines, the model with “four rings” badge features a modern design that suggests the Audi's "techno" orientation
Text: Miljan Terzić
foto: M. Terzić, Z. Živkov
miljan.terzic@vrelegume.rs
Translated by Pavle Barta
8132
Postavljeno: 21.12.2010

Arhiva: Uporedni testovi

Rubrika: Uporedni testovi
Postavljeno: 05.05.2018

Peugeot 308 1.2 Puretech 130 EAT8 i BMW Serie 1 118i/136 automatik

Dva agregata, šest cilindara i šesnaest brzina! Nezamislivo do još pre koju godinu! Peugeot 308 i BMW serije 1 danas bez kompleksa stavljaju u prvi plan trocilindarske agregate uz sofisticirane automatske menjače


Rubrika: Uporedni testovi
Postavljeno: 27.12.2017

Ford Fiesta 1.5 TDCi protiv VW Polo 1.0 TSI
Tekst sa video prilogom!

Jedna od tri najvažnije teme godine je pred nama. Naravno radi se o obračunu lidera B segmenta, Ford Fieste zvanično najprodavanijeg modela u ovoj klasi i Volkswagen Pola, slobodno možemo reći klasika malih automobila


Rubrika: Uporedni testovi
Postavljeno: 26.05.2015

Renault Twingo TCe/90 Dinamique vs. Smart Forfour
Tekst sa video prilogom!

Narodna fraza kojom se opisuju dve, po karakteru vrlo slične osobe, ali je svaka svojstvena sebi na svoj način, predstavlja vodeću karakteristiku dvoboja najmanjih mališana na tržištu


Ford Fiesta 1.6 TDCi vs Renault Clio 1.5 dCi Tekst sa video prilogom!

22.10.2014

Mazda 3 Sport 2.0i G165 / Mazda 3 Sport CD150

12.07.2014

Kia Cee’d 1.6 GDi / Kia Cee’d 1.6 CRDi

04.07.2014

Mercedes-Benz ML 350 i BMW X5

03.05.2014

VW Golf vs Peugeot 308

26.03.2014

Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V, Hyundai Santa Fe Tekst sa video prilogom!

21.06.2013

Audi A3 - BMW serija 1 - Mercedes-Benz A klase Tekst sa video prilogom!

24.05.2013

Mercedes A klasa i BMW Serija 1

16.11.2012

Mini Cooper S Coupe vs Renault Twingo Gordini

25.05.2012

Fiat Punto Classic vs Dacia Sandero

30.03.2012

Ford Kuga vs Jeep Compass vs Toyota RAV4

26.03.2012

Hyundai ix35 vs KIA Sportage English version Tekst sa video prilogom!

08.07.2011

Automobili cene do 10.000 evra

02.05.2011

Suzuki Swift vs Suzuki Swift English version

25.01.2011

Audi RS5 vs BMW M3 English version

03.01.2011

Audi A1 vs MINI Cooper English version

10.12.2010

Dacia Duster vs Chery Tiggo English version

26.11.2010

Citroen DS3 / Peugeot RCZ / Renault Megane RS

12.10.2010

Audi S5 Coupe vs Audi S5 Cabrio

18.06.2010

Mazda 3 i Kia Ceed

12.02.2010

Dacia Sandero Stepway i Suzuki SX4

25.12.2009

Lexus RX vs BMW X5 vs Audi Q7

18.11.2009

Alfa Romeo MiTo vs Mini Cooper S

13.10.2009

Opel Astra GTC i Kia Procee'd

14.07.2009

Hyundai i20 i Opel Corsa

11.06.2009

Mercedes C180 Kompressor i C220 CDI

26.05.2009

Toyota Avensis vs Honda Accord vs Mazda 6

04.05.2009

Hyundai i10 vs Kia Picanto

03.04.2009

Jeep Wrangler vs Land Rover Defender

06.03.2009

Automobilske navigacije

26.02.2009

Kolica za pijacu

31.12.2008

Fiat 500, Hyundai i10 i Suzuki Splash

04.11.2008

BMW X5 3,0d i VW Touareg 3,0 V6 TDI

22.07.2008

Pneumatici

23.05.2008

Citroen C6 2,7 HDi i Citroen DS 21 "Ajkula"

24.12.2007

Toyota Hilux 3,0 D-4D i Mutsubishi L200 2,5 DI-D

08.06.2007

Jeep Compass 2,3 i Suzuki Grand Vitara 2,0

25.01.2007

Mali automobili

28.12.2006

Jeep Grand Cherokee 3,0 CRDI i Range Rover Sport TD

20.11.2006

VW Jetta 1,9 TDI i Renault Megane Sedan 1,5 dCi

19.06.2006

Renault Megane 2,0 RS Luxe i Ford Focus ST 2,5T

09.05.2006

Toyota Hilux 2,5 D-4D i Isuzu D-Max 3,0 TD

09.02.2006

Citroen C3 1,6 HDi i Renault Clio 1,5 dCi

26.01.2006

Citroen C5 Break 2,0 HDi i Renault Laguna Estate 2,2 dCi

28.10.2005

Honda Jazz 1,4 i Mitsubishi Colt 1,3

23.06.2005

BMW 320i i 320d

25.05.2005

Peugeot 307 1,6 HDi i Renault Megane 1,5 dCi

18.03.2005

Peugeot 307 SW 2,0 HDi i Ford Focus C-Max 2,0 TDCi

28.02.2005

Mitsubishi Outlander, Nissan X-Trail i Toyota RAV4

22.12.2004

Audi A8 L 6,0 Quattro, Mercedes S 600 L i BMW 760 Li

19.11.2004

Citroen C2, Lancia Ypsilon i Nissan Micra

15.09.2004

Ford Sportka i Streetka

27.09.2004

OPEL Astra 1,6 Twinport Enjoy i VW Golf V 1,6 FSI Comfortline

21.08.2004

Supersportski automobili

25.07.2004

FIAT Panda 1,2 Emotion, OPEL Agila 1,0 Njoy Design i DAIHATSU Cuore 1,0 Top

22.06.2004

FORD Focus 1,8 TDCi 100KS i RENAULT Megane 1,5 dCi 100KS

20.05.2004

VW Golf V 2,0 TDi 16V 140 KS i PEUGEOT 307 2,0 HDi 16V 136 KS

13.04.2004

RENAULT Megane Sedan 1,9 dCi i SEAT Toledo 1,9 TDi

16.03.2004

VW Golf V i MAZDA 3

5.02.2004

CITROEN C2 i C3 1,4 16V 90KS Sensodrive

21.02.2004

PEUGEOT 307 CC 2,0 i RENAULT Megane CC 2,0

15.01.2004

RENAULT Megane Grandtour,
PEUGEOT 307 Break,
FIAT Stilo Multi Wagon i
MITSUBISHI Lancer Kombi

12.12.2003

BMW serija 5, MERCEDES E320 i AUDI A6

24.12.2003

CITROEN C2 1,4 i RENAULT Twingo 1,2 16V

5.11.2003

AUDI TT 3,2 Quattro, CHRYSLER Crossfire 3,2 i NISSAN 350 Z

17.11.2003

CITROEN Berlingo, FIAT Doblo, RENAULT Kangoo i OPEL Combo

8.10.2003

TERENSKA VOZILA

20.10.2003

HONDA Accord, MAZDA 6 i TOYOTA Avensis

30.08.2003

RENAULT Clio 2,0 RS i PEUGEOT 206 2,0 RC

13.09.2003

AUDI A3 2,0 FSI, BMW 318 ti Compact i MERCEDES C180 K Sportcoupe

16.08.2003

HONDA Jazz 1,4i LS, MAZDA 2 MZI 1,4 Exclusive i NISSAN Micra 1,2 Acenta

17.07.2003

ALFA ROMEO 147 GTA, FORD Focus RS i VW Golf R32

10.06.2003

RENAULT Megane 1,9 dCi, FORD Focus 1,8 TDCi i ŠKODA Octavia 1,9 TDI

27.04.2003

BMW X5 4,6is, MERCEDES ML55 AMG i PORSCHE Cayenne S

10.05.2003

FORD Ka Futura i RENAULT Twingo 1,2 16V Privilege

7.04.2003

FORD Mondeo TDCi Turnier i MAZDA 6 CD Sport-Kombi

7.03.2003

HYUNDAI Getz, DAEWOO Kalos i CITROEN C3

6.02.2003

SUBARU Forester 2,0 XT Turbo i ŠKODA Octavia Combi 1,8T

18.02.2003

PEUGEOT 307 110, RENAULT Megane 1,6 i VW Golf 1,6

18.01.2003

KIA Sorento CRD i TOYOTA Rav 4 D4D

21.12.2002

MASERATI Coupe Cambiocorsa i PORSCHE 911 Carrera

15.11.2002

MAZDA 6 1,8 Comfort, OPEL Vectra 1,8 Comfort i VW Passat 2,0 Comfortline

24.11.2002

PEUGEOT 206 SW i ŠKODA Fabia Combi

13.10.2002

HONDA Jazz 1,4i i SEAT Ibiza 1,4 16V

1.10.2002

MERCEDES S 600 i VW Phaeton W12

6.10.2002

TOYOTA RAV 4 D4D i SUZUKI Grand Vitara XL-7

3.09.2002

FORD Fiesta TDCi, PEUGEOT 206 HDi i CITROEN C3 HDi

3.09.2002

Pošaljite komentar:

Molimo vas da pre slanja komentara pročitate sledeće uputstvo:
Redakcija zadržava pravo izbora komentara koji će biti objavljeni, kao i pravo skraćivanja komentara.
Anonimni komentari se ne objavljuju.
Komentari koji sadrže vređanje, nepristojan govor, rasnu i nacionalnu mržnju kao i netoleranciju svake vrste neće biti objavljeni. Govor mržnje ne tolerišemo.
Zbog ograničenog prostora, komentare koji predstavljaju komentar drugih (već objavljenih) komentara ne objavljujemo, kao ni polemike između komentatora. Molimo vas da u svrhu diskusije i polemike koristite naš Forum.
Pre pisanja samog komentara, molimo vas da izaberete tačan tekst na koju se odnosi komentar. Komentari koji sadržajem ne korespondiraju sa tekstom sa koje su poslati neće biti objavljeni.
VRELE GUME ne odgovara za sadržaj objavljenih komentara. Mišljenja iznešena u komentarima su privatno mišljenje autora komentara i ne predstavljaju stavove redakcije.

Vaše ime:


Vaš komentar:



Anti-spam-kod:
Kako bi bili sigurni da ste osoba, a ne robot-spamer, molimo Vas da u donje polje unesete kod sa slike: